// DIET & NUTRITION APPS
MyFitnessPal vs Cronometer: Complete Diet Tracking App Comparison 2024
MyFitnessPal and Cronometer represent two distinct approaches to nutrition tracking, each with passionate user bases and unique strengths. MyFitnessPal, the veteran app with over 11 million food entries, has dominated the calorie counting space for years with its massive database and user-friendly interface. Cronometer, however, has emerged as the precision-focused alternative, emphasizing data accuracy and comprehensive micronutrient tracking over sheer database size. The choice between these apps often comes down to your priorities: do you value convenience and extensive food options, or do you prefer scientific accuracy and detailed nutritional insights? While MyFitnessPal excels at quick logging with its vast database and meal separation features, Cronometer stands out with verified nutritional data and comprehensive health tracking capabilities. Understanding these fundamental differences is crucial for making the right choice for your health optimization journey.
MyFitnessPal
$79
Cronometer
$49
[FEATURE COMPARISON]
| Feature | MyFitnessPal | Cronometer |
|---|---|---|
|
Food Database Size Total number of food entries available for logging |
11+ million entries (user-generated) | Verified database (smaller, curated entries) |
|
Data Accuracy Quality control and verification of nutritional information |
Mixed accuracy (green checkmark for verified entries) | High accuracy (all entries verified by curation team) |
|
Micronutrient Tracking Number of vitamins and minerals tracked beyond macros |
6 basic micronutrients only | Complete micronutrient profile (25+ vitamins/minerals) |
|
Meal Separation Ability to organize foods by meal timing throughout the day |
6 customizable meal categories (free version) | Single food list (meal separation requires Gold subscription) |
|
Copy/Paste Functionality Ease of replicating previous meals or days |
Copy yesterday's meal via swipe gesture | Advanced copy/paste with multi-select from any previous date |
|
Macro Customization Flexibility in setting macronutrient targets |
5% increments only (exact grams require premium) | Exact gram or percentage targets (free version) |
|
Health Integration Ability to track additional health metrics beyond food |
Basic measurements, exercise, water intake | Comprehensive: sleep, mood, lab results, biomarkers |
|
Recipe Features Tools for creating and managing custom recipes |
Separate recipe interface (different from daily logging) | Same interface as daily logging, 'explode recipe' feature |
[PROS & CONS]
MyFitnessPal
Pros
- Massive 11+ million food database with global entries
- Free meal separation into 6 customizable categories
- Intuitive interface with easy meal copying via swipe gestures
- Extensive chain restaurant database for dining out
- Large community and widespread device integration
Cons
- Mixed data accuracy with many user-generated errors
- Limited to only 6 basic micronutrients
- Premium required for exact macro targeting and barcode scanner
- Frequent ads and slower performance in free version
Cronometer
Pros
- 100% verified nutritional data with curation team review
- Comprehensive 25+ micronutrient tracking in free version
- Advanced copy/paste with multi-select from any previous date
- Flexible macro customization with exact gram targeting
- Extensive health tracking: sleep, mood, lab results, biomarkers
- Superior recipe management with 'explode recipe' feature
Cons
- Smaller food database with limited international entries
- Meal separation requires Gold subscription upgrade
- Steeper learning curve for MyFitnessPal converts
- Less convenient for frequent restaurant dining
[OUR VERDICT]
Cronometer wins with superior accuracy, comprehensive micronutrient tracking, and better value, making it ideal for serious health optimization despite MyFitnessPal's larger database.
The choice between MyFitnessPal and Cronometer ultimately depends on your tracking philosophy and health goals. MyFitnessPal excels as a user-friendly option for those who prioritize convenience, extensive food options, and quick logging. Its 11+ million food database, including chain restaurant entries, makes it invaluable for frequent travelers or those with varied diets. The free meal separation feature is particularly beneficial for athletes and fitness enthusiasts who need to track nutrient timing around workouts.
However, Cronometer emerges as the superior choice for users who prioritize accuracy and comprehensive health tracking. The verified database, though smaller, provides significantly more reliable nutritional data – crucial for those with specific health conditions or precise fitness goals. The complete micronutrient tracking (25+ vitamins and minerals vs. MyFitnessPal's 6) offers unprecedented insight into nutritional deficiencies, with users frequently discovering zinc, magnesium, and other micronutrient gaps they never knew existed.
From a value perspective, Cronometer's $49 price point delivers exceptional value considering its advanced features are available in the base version, while MyFitnessPal's $79 premium subscription is required for basic features like exact macro targeting and barcode scanning. The 10-20% accuracy variance inherent in all tracking apps is minimized with Cronometer's verified database, making it the clear winner for serious health optimization.
For BodyOS users focused on comprehensive health optimization, Cronometer's scientific approach, detailed reporting, and integration capabilities with health devices make it the recommended choice, despite the initial learning curve from MyFitnessPal's simpler interface.
Our pick:
Cronometer
Track MyFitnessPal and Cronometer in BodyOS
Connect your devices to see unified insights in one place.
[RELATED COMPARISONS]
Diet & Nutrition Apps
MacroFactor vs MyFitnessPal: Complete 2025 Macro Tracking App Comparison
MacroFactor wins with its AI-powered adaptive coaching, verified food database, and precision tracking that far exceeds MyFitnessPal's static approach.
Diet & Nutrition Apps
MacroFactor vs Carbon Diet Coach: Complete App Comparison Guide 2025
MacroFactor wins with its flexible, adherence-neutral approach and comprehensive tracking capabilities, making it more sustainable for most users despite Carbon's strong structure.
Diet & Nutrition Apps
YAZIO vs MyFitnessPal: Complete Nutrition App Comparison for 2025
YAZIO wins with better value, superior user experience, and integrated fasting features at $35 less annually than MyFitnessPal.