// SMART SCALES
Withings Body Comp vs InBody H20B: Complete Smart Scale Comparison Guide
Smart scales have revolutionized how we track body composition at home, offering insights far beyond simple weight measurements. The Withings Body Comp and InBody H20B represent two distinct approaches to advanced body analysis - the Withings focusing on comprehensive health metrics including cardiovascular monitoring, while the InBody emphasizes clinical-grade body composition accuracy derived from professional medical equipment. Both scales use bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) technology to measure body composition, but they target different user needs. The Withings Body Comp appeals to wellness enthusiasts seeking holistic health tracking with features like visceral fat analysis, nerve health assessment, and vascular age monitoring. The InBody H20B, drawing from the company's 25+ years of professional body composition analyzer experience, targets fitness-focused users who prioritize measurement precision and segmental body analysis. Understanding these fundamental differences is crucial for selecting the right scale for your health optimization journey.
Withings Body Comp
$200
InBody H20B
$250
[FEATURE COMPARISON]
| Feature | Withings Body Comp | InBody H20B |
|---|---|---|
|
Measurement Accuracy How closely the scale's readings match gold-standard methods like DEXA scans |
Multi-frequency BIA with handheld electrodes, 6-lead ECG integration | Direct Segmental Multi-Frequency BIA, 98% correlation with DEXA scans |
|
Body Composition Metrics Range and depth of body composition measurements provided |
Weight, body fat %, muscle mass, bone mass, water %, visceral fat, vascular age | Weight, skeletal muscle mass, body fat %, visceral fat, segmental analysis, body water |
|
Health Monitoring Features Additional health tracking capabilities beyond basic body composition |
6-lead ECG, nerve health (EDA), standing heart rate, pulse wave velocity | Basic body composition focus, no cardiovascular monitoring |
|
Technology & Electrodes Type of BIA technology and electrode configuration used |
Multi-frequency BIA with retractable handle electrodes | 8-point electrode system with 3 frequencies, DSM-BIA technology |
|
App Integration & Coaching Quality of companion app and integrated coaching features |
Withings Health Mate app, premium coaching requires $99/year subscription | InBody app with free personalized diet/fitness plans, no subscription fees |
|
User Management Number of user profiles and recognition capabilities |
Up to 8 user profiles with automatic recognition | Multiple user support with automatic user detection |
|
Display & Design Screen quality, build materials, and overall aesthetic |
Color LCD display, tempered glass, weather display, premium finish | LED display, professional medical device aesthetic, durable construction |
|
Connectivity & Power Connection options and power source specifications |
Wi-Fi + Bluetooth, rechargeable battery (12-month life), USB-C charging | Wi-Fi + Bluetooth, 4 AA batteries, cloud data sync |
[PROS & CONS]
Withings Body Comp
Pros
- 6-lead ECG and cardiovascular health monitoring
- Comprehensive health metrics including nerve health and vascular age
- Premium design with color LCD display and rechargeable battery
- Weather display and smart home integration features
- Up to 8 user profiles with excellent family sharing
Cons
- Premium coaching features require $99/year subscription
- Lower body composition accuracy compared to professional-grade devices
- Higher price point with ongoing costs for full functionality
InBody H20B
Pros
- Clinical-grade accuracy with 98% correlation to DEXA scans
- Professional 8-point electrode system with segmental analysis
- Free comprehensive app with personalized coaching and meal plans
- No subscription fees for any features
- Proven technology used in medical and professional settings
Cons
- Limited to body composition metrics only
- No cardiovascular or nerve health monitoring
- Basic LED display compared to competitors' color screens
[OUR VERDICT]
The InBody H20B wins for fitness-focused users prioritizing measurement accuracy and value, while the Withings Body Comp better serves those wanting comprehensive health monitoring with cardiovascular features.
The choice between the Withings Body Comp and InBody H20B ultimately depends on your primary health optimization goals and measurement priorities. The InBody H20B emerges as the clear winner for users focused on accurate body composition tracking and fitness progress monitoring. Its Direct Segmental Multi-Frequency BIA technology, validated with 98% correlation to DEXA scans, provides clinical-grade accuracy that surpasses most consumer devices. The 8-point electrode system and segmental analysis offer detailed insights into muscle distribution and body balance that serious fitness enthusiasts and athletes require.
For comprehensive wellness tracking beyond body composition, the Withings Body Comp offers compelling additional features including 6-lead ECG monitoring, nerve health assessment, and vascular age analysis. These cardiovascular health metrics provide valuable insights for users focused on overall wellness rather than just body composition. However, the $99 annual subscription requirement for premium coaching features significantly impacts its long-term value proposition compared to InBody's free comprehensive app experience.
From a accuracy and value standpoint, the InBody H20B provides superior measurement precision at a higher upfront cost but with no ongoing subscription fees. The included free personalized coaching, diet plans, and workout recommendations through the InBody app offer excellent long-term value. The Withings Body Comp, while offering more diverse health metrics, may appeal to users who prioritize convenience features like the color display and rechargeable battery over measurement precision.
For most BodyOS users focused on optimizing body composition, tracking fitness progress, and achieving specific physique goals, the InBody H20B represents the better investment. Its professional-grade accuracy, comprehensive free app ecosystem, and focus on actionable body composition data align better with serious health optimization efforts. The Withings Body Comp remains an excellent choice for users seeking a broader health monitoring device with cardiovascular insights, particularly those already invested in the Withings ecosystem.
Our pick:
InBody H20B
Track Withings Body Comp and InBody H20B in BodyOS
Connect your devices to see unified insights in one place.
[RELATED COMPARISONS]
Smart Scales
Withings Body+ vs Renpho Smart Scale: Complete 2024 Comparison Guide
Withings Body+ wins for accuracy and convenience, while Renpho Smart Scale offers unbeatable value for basic smart scale functionality.
Smart Scales
Withings Body Comp vs Tanita RD-545: Smart Scale Showdown 2025
The Withings Body Comp wins for most users with superior value, unique health metrics, and seamless connectivity, while the Tanita RD-545 excels for athletes needing segmental analysis precision.
Smart Scales
Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro vs Renpho Smart Scale: Complete Comparison Guide 2025
The Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro wins with superior ITO coating technology, dual connectivity options, and more comprehensive health metrics that justify its $20 premium over the Renpho.