// SMART SCALES
Garmin Index S2 vs Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro: Complete Smart Scale Comparison 2025
The smart scale market offers compelling options at different price points, with the Garmin Index S2 and Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro representing two distinct approaches to body composition tracking. The Garmin Index S2 targets fitness enthusiasts already invested in the Garmin ecosystem, offering seamless integration with Garmin Connect and specialized features for athletes. Meanwhile, the Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro focuses on delivering comprehensive metrics and family-friendly features at a budget-conscious price point. Both scales use bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) to measure body composition beyond just weight, but they differ significantly in their target audience, app experience, and advanced features. Understanding these differences is crucial for choosing the right scale for your health optimization journey on BodyOS, whether you prioritize athletic performance tracking or comprehensive family health monitoring.
Garmin Index S2
$150
Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro
$50
[FEATURE COMPARISON]
| Feature | Garmin Index S2 | Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro |
|---|---|---|
|
Price Point Initial purchase cost and overall value proposition |
$150 (premium pricing for Garmin ecosystem) | $50 (budget-friendly with comprehensive features) |
|
Measurement Technology Type of bioelectrical impedance analysis used for body composition |
Dual-frequency BIA for enhanced accuracy | Multi-frequency BIA with ITO coating electrodes |
|
Metrics Tracked Number and types of body composition measurements provided |
7 metrics: weight, BMI, body fat %, muscle mass, bone mass, water %, visceral fat | 16 metrics: includes heart rate, protein levels, body age, metabolic rate |
|
User Capacity Maximum number of user profiles supported |
16 users with auto-recognition | Unlimited users with auto-recognition |
|
Connectivity Options Wireless connection methods and reliability |
Wi-Fi only, auto-syncs to Garmin Connect | Wi-Fi + Bluetooth dual connectivity |
|
App Integration Compatible health apps and ecosystem support |
Garmin Connect exclusive, limited third-party integration | Apple Health, Google Fit, Fitbit, MyFitnessPal support |
|
Display Features On-scale information display capabilities |
Color LCD with trend arrows, shows weight and body fat | Full-color display with animated avatars and comprehensive metrics |
|
Special Modes Specialized features for different user types |
Athlete mode for highly trained individuals | Pregnancy mode, baby weighing mode, guest mode |
[PROS & CONS]
Garmin Index S2
Pros
- Seamless Garmin Connect integration for existing users
- Dual-frequency BIA technology for enhanced accuracy
- Athlete mode optimized for highly trained individuals
- Premium build quality with 9-month battery life
- Trend arrows displayed directly on scale
Cons
- Limited to Garmin ecosystem with poor third-party integration
- High price point at $150 for limited features
- Laggy color display with poor refresh rate
Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro
Pros
- Exceptional value at $50 with comprehensive features
- 16 detailed metrics including heart rate and body age
- Unlimited user capacity with family-friendly modes
- Broad app compatibility with major health platforms
- Engaging animated avatars and full-color display
Cons
- Less accurate for elite athletes compared to specialized scales
- Requires more frequent battery replacement every 6 months
- Smaller 11x11 inch platform may not suit larger users
[OUR VERDICT]
The Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro wins with superior value, comprehensive metrics (16 vs 7), and family-friendly features at one-third the price of the Garmin Index S2.
The choice between the Garmin Index S2 and Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro ultimately depends on your fitness ecosystem and budget priorities. The Garmin Index S2 excels as a specialized tool for serious athletes and existing Garmin users who value seamless data integration and trend visualization. Its dual-frequency BIA technology and athlete mode provide more accurate readings for highly trained individuals, while the trend arrows displayed on the scale offer immediate feedback for cutting or bulking phases. However, its $150 price point and limited app compatibility make it less appealing for general users.
The Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro delivers exceptional value at $50, offering more comprehensive metrics (16 vs 7) and superior versatility for families. Its unlimited user capacity, pregnancy-safe mode, and broad app compatibility make it ideal for households with diverse tracking needs. The animated avatars and color display create an engaging experience that motivates consistent use. While its single-frequency BIA may be slightly less accurate for elite athletes, it provides sufficient precision for general fitness tracking.
For BodyOS users prioritizing comprehensive health optimization data and family functionality, the Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro offers superior value and features. Its extensive metric tracking, including unique measurements like protein levels and body age, provides more actionable insights for overall health optimization. The significant cost savings can be allocated to other health optimization tools or professional assessments like DEXA scans for validation.
The Garmin Index S2 remains the better choice only for dedicated Garmin ecosystem users who prioritize athletic performance tracking over comprehensive family features. Its premium build quality and specialized athlete features justify the higher cost for this specific user group, but most BodyOS users will find better value and functionality with the Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro.
Our pick:
Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro
Track Garmin Index S2 and Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro in BodyOS
Connect your devices to see unified insights in one place.
[RELATED COMPARISONS]
Smart Scales
Withings Body Comp vs InBody H20B: Complete Smart Scale Comparison Guide
The InBody H20B wins for fitness-focused users prioritizing measurement accuracy and value, while the Withings Body Comp better serves those wanting comprehensive health monitoring with cardiovascular features.
Smart Scales
Withings Body+ vs Renpho Smart Scale: Complete 2024 Comparison Guide
Withings Body+ wins for accuracy and convenience, while Renpho Smart Scale offers unbeatable value for basic smart scale functionality.
Smart Scales
Withings Body Comp vs Tanita RD-545: Smart Scale Showdown 2025
The Withings Body Comp wins for most users with superior value, unique health metrics, and seamless connectivity, while the Tanita RD-545 excels for athletes needing segmental analysis precision.