// SMART SCALES
Garmin Index S2 vs Withings Body+: Complete Smart Scale Comparison 2024
Choosing the right smart scale can significantly impact your health optimization journey, and two popular options frequently compared are the Garmin Index S2 and Withings Body+. Both scales offer body composition tracking beyond simple weight measurement, but they cater to different user needs and ecosystems. The Garmin Index S2, priced at $150, targets fitness enthusiasts already invested in Garmin's ecosystem, offering comprehensive metrics and seamless integration with Garmin Connect. Meanwhile, the Withings Body+, at $100, provides excellent value with proven accuracy and specialized modes for different user types. Understanding the key differences between these scales is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with your health goals and existing fitness technology setup.
Garmin Index S2
$150
Withings Body+
$100
[FEATURE COMPARISON]
| Feature | Garmin Index S2 | Withings Body+ |
|---|---|---|
|
Weight Accuracy How precisely the scale measures body weight compared to medical-grade standards |
±0.2 kg deviation (mean absolute error 0.18 kg) | Lab-tested accuracy with patented position control technology |
|
Body Composition Metrics Range of body analysis measurements beyond basic weight |
6 metrics: Weight, BMI, body fat %, muscle mass, bone mass, body water % | 5 metrics: Weight, BMI, body fat %, muscle mass, bone mass, body water % |
|
Display Technology Screen type and information presentation on the scale |
High-contrast color OLED display with 5-second metric cycling | Standard LCD display with clear readout |
|
Connectivity & Sync How the scale connects and transfers data to your devices |
Wi-Fi enabled with automatic sync to Garmin Connect | Wi-Fi enabled with automatic sync, no phone proximity required |
|
Multi-User Support Number of individual user profiles the scale can maintain |
Up to 16 user profiles | Up to 8 user profiles |
|
Specialized Modes Custom tracking modes for specific user types or conditions |
Standard tracking only | Pregnancy mode, baby mode, athlete mode with specialized algorithms |
|
App Integration Compatible health and fitness applications |
Garmin Connect primary, limited third-party integration | Withings Health Mate, Apple Health, Google Fit, MyFitnessPal |
|
Platform Dimensions Physical size and weight capacity of the scale |
12.6 x 12.2 inches, 400 lb capacity | 12.8 x 12.8 inches, 400 lb capacity |
[PROS & CONS]
Garmin Index S2
Pros
- Premium color OLED display with excellent visibility
- Supports up to 16 user profiles for large households
- Seamless integration with Garmin Connect ecosystem
- Wi-Fi connectivity eliminates need for phone proximity
Cons
- Higher price point at $150
- Lower body composition accuracy (8.2% body fat deviation)
- Limited third-party app integration
- No specialized tracking modes for different user types
Withings Body+
Pros
- Lab-tested accuracy with patented position control technology
- Specialized modes for pregnancy, baby, and athlete tracking
- Excellent app ecosystem integration including Apple Health and Google Fit
- Better value at $100 with comprehensive features
- Intuitive Health Mate app with trend-focused approach
Cons
- Standard LCD display versus premium OLED
- Limited to 8 user profiles
- Slightly larger footprint at 12.8 x 12.8 inches
[OUR VERDICT]
The Withings Body+ wins with superior accuracy, specialized user modes, and better value at $50 less than the Garmin Index S2.
After extensive analysis of both scales, the Withings Body+ emerges as the superior choice for most users, despite the Garmin Index S2's higher price point. The Body+ delivers exceptional value through its lab-tested accuracy, particularly its patented position control technology that ensures consistent readings by guiding proper weight distribution. This accuracy advantage is significant, as one study mentioned in our research found the Body+ to be 'the most accurate smart scale on the market' based on independent lab testing.
The Withings Body+ also excels in user experience through its specialized modes - pregnancy, baby, and athlete modes provide tailored insights that the Index S2 simply cannot match. The athlete mode uses different algorithms for users who exercise 8+ hours per week with resting heart rates below 60 bpm, while pregnancy mode offers obstetrician-reviewed guidance. These features demonstrate Withings' commitment to serving diverse user needs beyond basic tracking.
While the Garmin Index S2 offers advantages like a superior color OLED display and support for 16 users (versus 8), these benefits don't justify the $50 price premium for most users. The Index S2's primary strength lies in its seamless integration with the Garmin ecosystem, making it ideal for dedicated Garmin users who want consolidated health data. However, its body composition accuracy shows higher deviation rates (8.2% for body fat, 13% for muscle mass) compared to the Body+.
For most health-conscious individuals, the Withings Body+ provides the best combination of accuracy, features, and value. Its comprehensive app ecosystem integration, proven track record, and specialized modes make it the smarter investment unless you're deeply committed to the Garmin platform.
Our pick:
Withings Body+
Track Garmin Index S2 and Withings Body+ in BodyOS
Connect your devices to see unified insights in one place.
[RELATED COMPARISONS]
Smart Scales
InBody H20B vs Tanita RD-545: Professional Smart Scale Comparison 2025
The InBody H20B wins with superior value, offering professional-grade accuracy and comprehensive metrics at $150 less than the Tanita RD-545.
Smart Scales
Withings Body Comp vs InBody H20B: Complete Smart Scale Comparison Guide
The InBody H20B wins for fitness-focused users prioritizing measurement accuracy and value, while the Withings Body Comp better serves those wanting comprehensive health monitoring with cardiovascular features.
Smart Scales
Withings Body Comp vs Tanita RD-545: Smart Scale Showdown 2025
The Withings Body Comp wins for most users with superior value, unique health metrics, and seamless connectivity, while the Tanita RD-545 excels for athletes needing segmental analysis precision.